Friday, September 14, 2018

Let Freedom Ring

In May of this year, our marching band had its annual orientation meeting to officially announce the theme of the halftime show for the upcoming marching season. When applause rang through the auditorium following Mr. Nutting's declaration of the show title as "Let Freedom Ring," I clapped along with the rest of the audience, but I couldn't help my rising skepticism. Though I had no doubt that the band would be able to pull off a musically and visually brilliant performance, I had a hard time understanding why anyone would want to celebrate our country in such a way in light of the current state of our government. Why were we expressing pride in America when so many issues remained unresolved and the state of the nation seemed to be growing worse rather than improving?

While I've grown to love our performance over the course of this season because of the impact that music has on me and the many memories that I have come to associate with the show, it really wasn't until I considered redefining what patriotism means to me that I began to grasp the true meaning of our display. Being patriotic isn't about fireworks, parades, or wearing red, white, and blue. Being patriotic isn't about agreeing with every action of your government, or even about being proud of your country one-hundred percent of the time. Patriotism means something different to everyone, but to me, the essence of patriotism is having an investment in your country and caring about its future. Caring enough to not turn away and disassociate yourself from it in trying times. Caring enough to be fundamental in the change you want to see happen. Caring enough to bring others up and serve as inspiration in spite of negativity as our show seeks to do. Not everyone needs to take action as radical as what Thoreau suggests in On the Duty of Civil Disobedience, but every citizen can do something. Because sometimes, in the face of adversity, something is all we can do. As Sarah Vowell states in The Partly Cloudy Patriot, we wouldn't feel such regret with regards to the state of our nation, "if we didn't care so very, very much about how this country is run."

4 comments:

  1. Hey Katie! This post had a really interesting approach to the meaning of the word patriotic. I liked how you tied in quotes from the readings we discussed in class. Your post made me think about how true it is that it's hard to support a nation with so many issues. But in the end, we all care about our country and want to see it succeed, which means standing up for what we believe in.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love the way you defined the word patriot, you branched off of Sarah Vowell's work to show what patriotism means to you. Your response to the piece is well structured and really makes your point on patriotism clear. One particular sentence stood out to me as important was "the essence of patriotism is having an investment in your country and caring about its future." To me this is exactly what patriotism is, and like you mentioned earlier, it's not the celebration of the holiday that matters, but rather the support we hold for our country without fear of pointing out its wrongs and applauding the things it does right.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Katie!

    I really like the way you were able to start with an anecdote and connect it to your own personal dilemma about what patriotism is. It kind of emulates the style of writing that Sarah Vowell has.
    I also think you really hit the heart of what patriotism really is with your use of repetition "caring enough...".
    I really enjoyed your piece!

    Jennifer Hu, Fifth Hour

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it's super cool how you related this theme back to marching band, it really shows off a good understanding of the text, and I completely agree with you. I think that instead of celebrating freedom, we should start raising awareness for injustices brought in forms of racism, and hate. Really cool post Katie

    ReplyDelete